Paper · 2021 · Molecular Plant Pathology

Glutathione contributes to resistance responses to TMV through a differential modulation of salicylic acid and reactive oxygen species

Feng Zhu; Qi‐Ping Zhang; Yan‐Ping Che; et al.

20
claims
40
verbatim quotes
66
citations
3
research areas
✓
Open access · cc-by-nc-nd

Abstract

Systemic acquired resistance (SAR) is induced by pathogens and confers protection against a broad range of pathogens. Several SAR signals have been characterized, but the nature of the other unknown signalling by small metabolites in SAR remains unclear. Glutathione (GSH) has long been implicated in the defence reaction against biotic stress. However, the mechanism that GSH increases plant tolerance against virus infection is not entirely known. Here, a combination of a chemical, virus-induced gene-silencing-based genetics approach, and transgenic technology was undertaken to investigate the role of GSH in plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana. Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) infection results in increasing the expression of GSH biosynthesis genes NbECS and NbGS, and GSH content. Silencing of NbECS or NbGS accelerated oxidative damage, increased accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), compromised plant resistance to TMV, and suppressed the salicylic acid (SA)-mediated signalling pathway. Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator) alleviated oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, elevated plant local and systemic resistance, enhanced the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes. However, treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) accelerated oxidative damage, elevated ROS accumulation, compromised plant systemic resistance, suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and reduced the expression of ROS-regulating genes. Overexpression of NbECS reduced oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, increased resistance to TMV, activated the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of the ROS scavenging-related genes. We present molecular evidence suggesting GSH is essential for both local and systemic resistance of N. benthamiana to TMV through a differential modulation of SA and ROS.

Abstract from the paper’s OpenAlex record; open copy licensed cc-by-nc-nd. Read at the source ↗

The text the model read, with the source record’s inline markup (italics, sub- and superscripts) rendered and its character entities decoded; quote offsets refer to the raw text.

Claims 20

Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

TMV infection increased the expression of GSH biosynthesis genes NbECS and NbGS and GSH content in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) infectione1
Interactor
Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)Tobacco mosaic viruse1pathogen
Gene
NbECS and NbGSe1
Outcome
expression of GSH biosynthesis genes NbECS and NbGS, and GSH contente1
Direction
increasinge1

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗
Tobacco mosaic virus
Tobacco mosaic virus · InteractorFrank Vincentz · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e1

“Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) infection results in increasing the expression of GSH biosynthesis genes NbECS and NbGS, and GSH content”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 663–794 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Silencing of NbECS or NbGS accelerated oxidative damage in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Silencing of NbECS or NbGSe2
Gene
NbECS or NbGSe2
Outcome
oxidative damagee2
Direction
acceleratede2

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e2

“Silencing of NbECS or NbGS accelerated oxidative damage, increased accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), compromised plant resistance to TMV, and suppressed the salicylic acid (SA)-mediated signalling pathway”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 796–1013 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Silencing of NbECS or NbGS increased ROS accumulation in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Silencing of NbECS or NbGSe2
Gene
NbECS or NbGSe2
Outcome
accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS)e2
Direction
increasede2

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e2

“Silencing of NbECS or NbGS accelerated oxidative damage, increased accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), compromised plant resistance to TMV, and suppressed the salicylic acid (SA)-mediated signalling pathway”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 796–1013 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Silencing of NbECS or NbGS compromised plant resistance to TMV.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Silencing of NbECS or NbGSe2
Gene
NbECS or NbGSe2
Outcome
plant resistance to TMVe2
Direction
compromisede2

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e2

“Silencing of NbECS or NbGS accelerated oxidative damage, increased accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), compromised plant resistance to TMV, and suppressed the salicylic acid (SA)-mediated signalling pathway”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 796–1013 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Silencing of NbECS or NbGS suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Silencing of NbECS or NbGSe2
Gene
NbECS or NbGSe2
Outcome
salicylic acid (SA)-mediated signalling pathwaye2
Direction
suppressede2

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e2

“Silencing of NbECS or NbGS accelerated oxidative damage, increased accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), compromised plant resistance to TMV, and suppressed the salicylic acid (SA)-mediated signalling pathway”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 796–1013 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Application of GSH or its activator alleviated oxidative damage in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator)e3
Compound
GSHe3
Outcome
oxidative damagee3
Direction
alleviatede3

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e3

“Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator) alleviated oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, elevated plant local and systemic resistance, enhanced the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1015–1304 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Application of GSH or its activator decreased ROS accumulation in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator)e3
Compound
GSHe3
Outcome
accumulation of ROSe3
Direction
decreasede3

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e3

“Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator) alleviated oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, elevated plant local and systemic resistance, enhanced the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1015–1304 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Application of GSH or its activator elevated local and systemic resistance of N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator)e3
Compound
GSHe3
Outcome
plant local and systemic resistancee3
Direction
elevatede3

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e3

“Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator) alleviated oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, elevated plant local and systemic resistance, enhanced the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1015–1304 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Application of GSH or its activator enhanced the SA-mediated signalling pathway in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator)e3
Compound
GSHe3
Outcome
SA-mediated signalling pathwaye3
Direction
enhancede3

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e3

“Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator) alleviated oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, elevated plant local and systemic resistance, enhanced the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1015–1304 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Application of GSH or its activator increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator)e3
Gene
ROS scavenging-related genese3
Compound
GSHe3
Outcome
expression of ROS scavenging-related genese3
Direction
increasede3

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e3

“Application of GSH or l-2-oxothiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (a GSH activator) alleviated oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, elevated plant local and systemic resistance, enhanced the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1015–1304 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) accelerated oxidative damage in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor)e4
Outcome
oxidative damagee4
Direction
acceleratede4

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e4

“However, treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) accelerated oxidative damage, elevated ROS accumulation, compromised plant systemic resistance, suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and reduced the expression of ROS-regulating genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1306–1564 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) elevated ROS accumulation in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor)e4
Outcome
ROS accumulatione4
Direction
elevatede4

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e4

“However, treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) accelerated oxidative damage, elevated ROS accumulation, compromised plant systemic resistance, suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and reduced the expression of ROS-regulating genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1306–1564 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) compromised systemic resistance of N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor)e4
Outcome
plant systemic resistancee4
Direction
compromisede4

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e4

“However, treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) accelerated oxidative damage, elevated ROS accumulation, compromised plant systemic resistance, suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and reduced the expression of ROS-regulating genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1306–1564 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor)e4
Outcome
SA-mediated signalling pathwaye4
Direction
suppressede4

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e4

“However, treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) accelerated oxidative damage, elevated ROS accumulation, compromised plant systemic resistance, suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and reduced the expression of ROS-regulating genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1306–1564 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) reduced the expression of ROS-regulating genes in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor)e4
Gene
ROS-regulating genese4
Outcome
expression of ROS-regulating genese4
Direction
reducede4

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e4

“However, treatment with buthionine sulfoximine (a GSH inhibitor) accelerated oxidative damage, elevated ROS accumulation, compromised plant systemic resistance, suppressed the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and reduced the expression of ROS-regulating genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1306–1564 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Overexpression of NbECS reduced oxidative damage in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Overexpression of NbECSe5
Gene
NbECSe5
Outcome
oxidative damagee5
Direction
reducede5

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e5

“Overexpression of NbECS reduced oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, increased resistance to TMV, activated the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of the ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1566–1786 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Overexpression of NbECS decreased ROS accumulation in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Overexpression of NbECSe5
Gene
NbECSe5
Outcome
accumulation of ROSe5
Direction
decreasede5

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e5

“Overexpression of NbECS reduced oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, increased resistance to TMV, activated the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of the ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1566–1786 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Overexpression of NbECS increased resistance of N. benthamiana to TMV.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Overexpression of NbECSe5
Gene
NbECSe5
Outcome
resistance to TMVe5
Direction
increasede5

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e5

“Overexpression of NbECS reduced oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, increased resistance to TMV, activated the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of the ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1566–1786 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Overexpression of NbECS activated the SA-mediated signalling pathway in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Overexpression of NbECSe5
Gene
NbECSe5
Outcome
SA-mediated signalling pathwaye5
Direction
activatede5

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e5

“Overexpression of NbECS reduced oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, increased resistance to TMV, activated the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of the ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1566–1786 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Overexpression of NbECS increased the expression of ROS scavenging-related genes in N. benthamiana.

Taxon
Nicotiana benthamianaNicotiana benthamianae0
Treatment
Overexpression of NbECSe5
Gene
ROS scavenging-related genese5
Outcome
expression of the ROS scavenging-related genese5
Direction
increasede5

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana benthamiana
Nicotiana benthamiana · TaxonCharles Andres · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“plant viral resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 614–661 · show in text ↑
e5

“Overexpression of NbECS reduced oxidative damage, decreased accumulation of ROS, increased resistance to TMV, activated the SA-mediated signalling pathway, and increased the expression of the ROS scavenging-related genes”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1566–1786 · show in text ↑

loss of function · physiology: oxidative · Nicotiana benthamianaPositive and negative results

16 papers: 6 positive, 10 negative or no effect

9 papers in the same direction as this paper · 6 in the opposite direction

  1. positive
  2. positive
  3. positive

12 papers more in this group

See all 16 papers →

loss of function · disease · Nicotiana benthamianaPositive and negative results

143 papers: 50 positive, 93 negative or no effect

92 papers in the same direction as this paper · 50 in the opposite direction

  1. positive
  2. positive
  3. positive

139 papers more in this group

See all 143 papers →

loss of function · physiology: hormones · Nicotiana benthamianaResults agree

4 papers: 0 positive, 4 negative or no effect

3 papers in the same direction as this paper

  1. negative
  2. negative
  3. negative
See all 4 papers →

Claims are grouped by organism, treatment and what was measured or targeted. A paper counts as positive when any of its claims in the group is positive.