Intervention effectmodel-written summary

Rice yield was higher with the combined formula than N alone.

A claim from Study on the Formula of Special Ear Fertilizer for Rice and Wheat · 2004

Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Rice yield was higher with the combined formula than N alone.

Treatment
N, P, K and Si, Zn( Mn) with a suitable formulae0
Outcome
yields of ricee0
Direction
highere0
Comparator
applying N onlye0
Setting
field teste0

Not reportedMaterialGeneCompoundOrgan / stageInteractorInteractor roleSecond interactorSecond interactor roleValueQualifier

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“The results of field test showed that the yields of rice and wheat while applying N, P, K and Si, Zn( Mn) with a suitable formula were higher compared with applying N only.”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–172

Title

Study on the Formula of Special Ear Fertilizer for Rice and Wheat

Xiuying Zhu; Chu Liang; Mei Guifang 2004

Other claims from this paper (3)

Record rev-7ae1deef7e4480da39bbd7e46e9ba3210519ecacdbe1f670e95a2315e047b8e1 · schema claims-v0.9 · position 1 in the model’s answer

manganese atom · yield · Oryza sativa (rice)Results differ

27 papers: 23 positive, 4 negative or no effect

22 papers in the same direction as this claim · 4 in the opposite direction

  1. negative
    Root hair production is inhibited with increasing Mn concentrations.

    RICE PLANT STRUCTURAL CHANGES BY ADDITION OF EXCESS MANGANESE · 2002

    Opposite direction

  2. negative
    In a glasshouse pot experiment, soil amendment with calcium silicate or rice husk ash (with and without Mn) significantly improved rice yield-related components and yield compared with the Si-free control at P < 0.05.

    Comparative evaluation on calcium silicate and rice husk ash amendment for silicon-based fertilization of Malaysian rice (Oryza sativa L.) varieties · 2021 · compared with control (Si-free treatment)

    Opposite directionAbout lacking this nutrient, so it counts the other way round

  3. no effect
    Additional manganese did not change rice yield or iron or manganese uptake.

    Response to iron and manganese application as affected by their availability in a Typic Natraqualf · 1994

    Opposite direction

  4. negative
    Application of Fe and Mn caused a significant reduction in yield and yield components compared with control in rice.

    INFLUNENCE OF SEASONAL FLOODING PERIOD AND THE APPLICATION OF ZINC, IRON, AND MANGANESE ON THE AVAILABILITY OF APPLIED PHOSPHOROUS, GROWTH AND YIELD OF RICE. · 1998 · compared with control

    Opposite direction

  5. positive
    Mn addition to the solution gave a gain in dry matter yield of rice.

    Rice grown in nutrient solution with doses of manganese and silicon · 2010

    Same direction

  6. positive
    Zn 10 kg/ha, iron 15 kg/ha and Mn 5 kg/ha gave the maximum rice yield among the treatments.

    Effect of Zinc, Iron and Manganese Levels on Quality, Micro and Macro Nutrients Content of Rice and Their Relationship with Yield · 2017 · compared with the treatments

    Same direction

  7. positive
    In untreated soil, 25 mg kg−1 Mn increased grain and straw yield over control.

    EFFECT OF IRON AND MANGANESE INTERACTION ON PADDY YIELD AND IRON AND MANGANESE NUTRITION IN SILICON-TREATED AND UNTREATED SOILS · 1989 · compared with control

    Same direction

  8. positive
    Manganese addition increased lowland rice grain yield in a quadratic fashion.

    Requirement of Micronutrients by Lowland Rice · 2014

    Same direction

18 papers more in this group

See all 27 papers →

silicon atom · yield · Oryza sativa (rice)Results differ

218 papers: 202 positive, 16 negative or no effect

201 papers in the same direction as this claim · 16 in the opposite direction

  1. no effect
    Silicon without fungicides and fungicides at full rate without silicon showed no differences in yield in upland rice.

    Effects of Silicon and Fungicides on the Control of Leaf and Neck Blast in Upland Rice · 2004 · compared with fungicides (full rate) without Si

    Opposite directionAbout lacking this nutrient, so it counts the other way round

  2. no effect
    Silicon application produced no significant yield difference under high silica availability.

    Growth and canopy structure of rice plants grown under field conditions as affected by Si application · 2002 · compared with without Si application

    Opposite direction

  3. negative
    Yield of rice was depressed at the higher Si rate (500 kg ha−1 compared with 250 kg ha−1) with potassium and sodium silicates in sandy-loam soil under W2 irrigation.

    Effects of different sources of silicon and irrigation regime on rice yield components and silicon dynamics in the plant and soil · 2020 · compared with 250 kg ha−1

    Opposite direction

  4. negative
    Pretreated water-stressed upland rice showed a 14.6% reduction in grain yield compared with pretreated well-watered plants.

    Silicon and bioagents pretreatments synergistically improve upland rice performance during water stress · 2023 · compared with pretreated well-watered plants

    Opposite direction

  5. no effect
    Se or Si spray did not affect P1 and P2 yields

    Performances of Water Management, Foliage Dressing, and Variation Screening in Controlling the Accumulation of As and Cd and Maintaining the Concentrations of Essential Elements in the Grains of Rice Plant · 2018

    Opposite direction

  6. no effect
    Applying Si did not significantly influence rice grain yield.

    The Potential Role of Zinc and Silicon in Improving Grain Yield and Lodging Resistance of Rice (Oryza sativa L.) · 2023

    Opposite direction

  7. no effect
    Silicon application did not increase yield in this study.

    Empirical Study on Effect of Silicon Application on Rice Blast Disease and Plant Morphology in Indonesia · 2016

    Opposite direction

  8. no effect
    Silica application did not increase yield.

    Influence of Water Management and Silica Application on Rice Growth and Productivity in Central Java, Indonesia · 2016

    Opposite direction

209 papers more in this group

See all 218 papers →

zinc atom · yield · Oryza sativa (rice)Results differ

419 papers: 389 positive, 30 negative or no effect

388 papers in the same direction as this claim · 28 in the opposite direction · 2 reporting no difference from an alternative

  1. no effect
    Foliar-applied Zn, I, Fe or Se did not affect rice grain yield.

    Simultaneous Biofortification of Rice With Zinc, Iodine, Iron and Selenium Through Foliar Treatment of a Micronutrient Cocktail in Five Countries · 2020 · compared with local control (LC)

    Opposite direction

  2. negative
    Foliar Zn application at a late stage was not as effective as soil application in increasing yield attributes and yield of rice.

    Relative Efficiency of Zinc-Coated Urea and Soil and Foliar Application of Zinc Sulphate on Yield, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium, Zinc and Iron Biofortification in Grains and Uptake by Basmati Rice (Oryza sativa L.) · 2015 · compared with soil application

    Opposite direction

  3. no effect
    Following green manure, reduced P, K, S and Zn doses did not reduce T. Aman yield.

    Long‐Term Integrated Nutrient Management for Rice‐Based Cropping Pattern: Effect on Growth, Yield, Nutrient Uptake, Nutrient Balance Sheet, and Soil Fertility · 2007

    Opposite direction

  4. no effect
    Zinc fertilization did not significantly increase rice productivity.

    Long-Term Effects of Sulfur and Zinc Fertilization on Rice Productivity and Nutrient Efficiency in Double Rice Cropping Paddy in Bangladesh · 2015

    Opposite direction

  5. no effect
    Foliar zinc spraying did not affect rice grain yield in any field.

    Effects of Foliar Application of Zinc on Grain Yield and Zinc Concentration of Rice in Farmers’ Fields · 2018

    Opposite direction

  6. negative
    Zinc fertilizer might reduce rice yields in high-M3Zn fields.

    DEVELOPMENT OF A CRITICAL MEHLICH 3 SOIL ZINC CONCENTRATION FOR RICE IN ARKANSAS · 2002

    Opposite direction

  7. negative
    Zn fertilizer decreased grain yield by 11.9% in the wetland rice variety CNT1 compared with no Zn fertilizer.

    Improving Grain Zinc Concentration in Wetland and Upland Rice Varieties Grown under Waterlogged and Well-Drained Soils by Applying Zinc Fertilizer · 2021 · compared with without Zn fertilizer application

    Opposite direction

  8. negative
    Foliar zinc at 60 DAT yielded a minimum of 220.28 productive tillers per m2.

    Effect of method and time of zinc application on growth and yield of rice (Oryza sativa L.) · 2011 · compared with basal application at the rate 25 kg ha-1 21 % ZnSO4

    Opposite direction

410 papers more in this group

See all 419 papers →

3 of 6 groups shown: named compounds and organisms first, then groups whose results differ (checked claim by claim), then those with positive and negative results, then the smaller groups.

Claims are grouped by organism, treatment and what was measured or targeted. A paper counts as positive when any of its claims in the group is positive.