Paper · 2019 · University of Alberta Library

Role of Aquaporins in Plant Responses to Oxygen Deprivation

Tan, Xiangfeng

20
claims
42
verbatim quotes
0
citations
3
research areas
✓
Open access

Abstract

Oxygen deprivation (hypoxia and anoxia) is an environmental stress affecting plants worldwide in many natural and man-made ecosystems. Aquaporins exhibit multiple physiological functions in challenging environments. The central role of aquaporins in plant water relations has been widely acknowledged, but the role of aquaporins under O2 deficiency remains elusive. Growing evidence has shown that aquaporins are involved in pore-mediated gas trans-membrane movement. In this thesis, Arabidopsis thaliana, tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) and trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) seedlings were studied to shed more light on the responses of aquaporins to root hypoxia. Oxygen transport through aquaporins was also examined in yeast heterologously expressing aquaporins from plant, human and fungal organisms. In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment, plants produced twice as many adventitious roots as the aerated plants, but their maximum length was reduced. Hypoxia severely reduced net photosynthesis, transpiration rates, and photosynthetic light responses. Relative transcript abundance of the examined aquaporins in lateral roots was reduced by hypoxia, but in adventitious roots it remained unchanged. This apparent lack of an effect of root hypoxia on the aquaporin expression likely contributed to maintenance of high hydraulic conductance in adventitious roots. Lateral roots had lower porosity compared with adventitious roots and the expression of the ACS (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate synthase) gene was induced in hypoxic lateral roots, but not in adventitious roots, providing additional evidence that lateral roots were more affected by hypoxia compared with adventitious roots. ATP concentrations were markedly lower in both hypoxic lateral and adventitious roots compared with aerated roots, while the expression of fermentation-related genes, ADH1 (alcohol dehydrogenase 1) and PDC1 (pyruvate decarboxylase 1), was higher in lateral roots compared with adventitious roots. Since root porosity was greater in adventitious compared with lateral roots, the results suggest that the improved O2 delivery and stable root aquaporin expression in adventitious roots were likely the key factors helping flooded tobacco plants maintain high rates of root hydraulic conductance and, consequently, shoot gas exchange. Effects of ethylene on hypoxia tolerance in plants are little understood. In this thesis research, I examined the physiology and gene expression of several aquaporins in aspen (Populus tremuloides) seedlings exposed to root hypoxia and treated with exogenous ethylene. Ethylene enhanced net photosynthesis, light saturation level for net photosynthesis, transpiration rates, and root hydraulic conductance in hypoxic plants. Root O2 concentrations increased in the hypoxic plants treated with ethylene compared to the hypoxic plants that were not subjected to ethylene treatment. The effect of ethylene on root O2 content could be either due to the enhanced net photosynthesis or facilitated O2 transport from shoots. Ethylene triggered the expression of PIP2;4 aquaporin in hypoxic aspen which could potentially help facilitate root water transport. The enhanced root water transport by ethylene could be also partly responsible for the increase in net photosynthesis of the hypoxic plants which, in turn, could enhance root O2 supply. Arabidopsis seedlings were subjected to waterlogging and compared with well-aerated plants. Photosynthesis and transpiration were inhibited by waterlogging. Waterlogging increased the relative transcript abundance of ADH, PDC-1, and NIP2;1 in plants. After 24 and 48 hours of waterlogging, relative transcript abundance of most of the PIPs decreased, while PIP1;1 and PIP1;4 in waterlogged roots exhibited significantly higher relative transcript abundance compared with aerated roots suggesting that they may play a role in plant resistance mechanisms under hypoxic conditions. O2 permeability of various human, plant, and fungal aquaporins was examined by co-expressing heterologous aquaporin and myoglobin in yeast. Two of the most promising O2-transporters (Homo sapiens AQP1 and N. tabacum PIP1;3) were confirmed to facilitate O2 transport in further spectrophotometric assay using yeast protoplasts. The over-expression of NtPIP1;3 in yeasts significantly increased their O2 uptake rates in suspension culture. In N. tabacum roots subjected to hypoxic conditions in hydroponic culture, it demonstrated a sharp increase in the relative transcript abundance of the O2-transporting aquaporin NtPIP1;3 after seven-day hypoxia treatment, accompanied by the increase in root ATP levels, particularly in the apical root segments. The results show that the functional significance of aquaporin-mediated O2 transport should be considered in further studies and that the possibility of controlling the rate of transmembrane O2 transport should be further explored.

Abstract from the paper’s OpenAlex record, shown for indexing and research. Copyright remains with the authors or the publisher. Read at the source ↗

The text the model read, with the source record’s inline markup (italics, sub- and superscripts) rendered and its character entities decoded; quote offsets refer to the raw text.

Claims 20

Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Root hypoxia for one week doubled the number of adventitious roots in tobacco relative to aerated plants.

Treatment
root hypoxia treatmente0
Outcome
adventitious rootse1
Direction
twice as manye1
Value
twicee1
Comparator
aerated plantse1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e1

“plants produced twice as many adventitious roots as the aerated plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 870–940 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Root hypoxia reduced the maximum length of the adventitious roots of tobacco.

Treatment
root hypoxia treatmente0
Outcome
maximum lengthe2
Direction
reducede2

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e2

“but their maximum length was reduced”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 942–978 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Hypoxia severely reduced net photosynthesis, transpiration rates and photosynthetic light responses in tobacco.

Treatment
Hypoxiae3
Outcome
net photosynthesis, transpiration rates, and photosynthetic light responsese3
Direction
severely reducede3

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e3

“Hypoxia severely reduced net photosynthesis, transpiration rates, and photosynthetic light responses”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 980–1080 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Hypoxia reduced the relative transcript abundance of the examined aquaporins in lateral roots of tobacco.

Organ / stage
lateral rootse4
Treatment
hypoxiae4
Gene
aquaporinse4
Outcome
Relative transcript abundancee4
Direction
reducede4

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e4

“Relative transcript abundance of the examined aquaporins in lateral roots was reduced by hypoxia, but in adventitious roots it remained unchanged”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1082–1227 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultno effectmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Hypoxia left the relative transcript abundance of the examined aquaporins unchanged in adventitious roots of tobacco.

Organ / stage
adventitious rootse4
Treatment
hypoxiae4
Gene
aquaporinse4
Outcome
Relative transcript abundancee4
Direction
remained unchangede4

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e4

“Relative transcript abundance of the examined aquaporins in lateral roots was reduced by hypoxia, but in adventitious roots it remained unchanged”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1082–1227 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Lateral roots of tobacco had lower porosity than adventitious roots.

Organ / stage
Lateral rootse5
Outcome
porositye5
Direction
lowere5
Comparator
adventitious rootse5

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e5

“Lateral roots had lower porosity compared with adventitious roots”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1392–1457 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Hypoxia induced expression of the ACS (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate synthase) gene in lateral roots of tobacco but not in adventitious roots.

Organ / stage
lateral rootse6
Treatment
hypoxice6
Gene
ACS (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate synthase)e6
Outcome
expressione6
Direction
inducede6
Qualifier
but not in adventitious rootse6

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e6

“the expression of the ACS (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate synthase) gene was induced in hypoxic lateral roots, but not in adventitious roots”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1462–1605 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

ATP concentrations were markedly lower in both hypoxic lateral and adventitious roots of tobacco than in aerated roots.

Organ / stage
lateral and adventitious rootse7
Treatment
hypoxice7
Outcome
ATP concentrationse7
Direction
lowere7
Comparator
aerated rootse7

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e7

“ATP concentrations were markedly lower in both hypoxic lateral and adventitious roots compared with aerated roots”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1720–1833 · show in text ↑
Associationobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Expression of ADH1 and PDC1 was higher in lateral roots than in adventitious roots of tobacco.

Organ / stage
lateral rootse1
Gene
ADH1 (alcohol dehydrogenase 1) and PDC1 (pyruvate decarboxylase 1)e1
Outcome
expressione1
Direction
highere1
Comparator
adventitious rootse1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In tobacco, after one week of root hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 816–868 · show in text ↑
e1

“the expression of fermentation-related genes, ADH1 (alcohol dehydrogenase 1) and PDC1 (pyruvate decarboxylase 1), was higher in lateral roots compared with adventitious roots”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1841–2015 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Ethylene enhanced net photosynthesis, light saturation level for net photosynthesis and transpiration rates in hypoxic aspen seedlings.

Taxon
aspene0
Treatment
Ethylenee1
Outcome
net photosynthesis, light saturation level for net photosynthesis, transpiration ratese1
Direction
enhancede1
Comparator
the hypoxic plants that were not subjected to ethylene treatmente2

Verbatim

e0

“aspen (Populus tremuloides) seedlings”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2521–2558 · show in text ↑
e1

“Ethylene enhanced net photosynthesis, light saturation level for net photosynthesis, transpiration rates, and root hydraulic conductance in hypoxic plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2620–2774 · show in text ↑
e2

“the hypoxic plants that were not subjected to ethylene treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2865–2929 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Ethylene enhanced root hydraulic conductance in hypoxic aspen seedlings.

Taxon
aspene0
Treatment
Ethylenee1
Outcome
root hydraulic conductancee1
Direction
enhancede1
Comparator
the hypoxic plants that were not subjected to ethylene treatmente2

Verbatim

e0

“aspen (Populus tremuloides) seedlings”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2521–2558 · show in text ↑
e1

“Ethylene enhanced net photosynthesis, light saturation level for net photosynthesis, transpiration rates, and root hydraulic conductance in hypoxic plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2620–2774 · show in text ↑
e2

“the hypoxic plants that were not subjected to ethylene treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2865–2929 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Ethylene increased root O2 concentrations in hypoxic aspen seedlings.

Taxon
aspene0
Treatment
ethylenee1
Outcome
Root O2 concentrationse1
Direction
increasede1
Comparator
the hypoxic plants that were not subjected to ethylene treatmente2

Verbatim

e0

“aspen (Populus tremuloides) seedlings”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2521–2558 · show in text ↑
e1

“Root O2 concentrations increased in the hypoxic plants treated with ethylene”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2776–2852 · show in text ↑
e2

“the hypoxic plants that were not subjected to ethylene treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2865–2929 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Ethylene triggered expression of the PIP2;4 aquaporin in hypoxic aspen.

Taxon
aspene0
Treatment
Ethylenee0
Gene
PIP2;4 aquaporine0
Outcome
expressione0
Direction
triggerede0

Not reportedComparator

Verbatim

e0

“Ethylene triggered the expression of PIP2;4 aquaporin in hypoxic aspen”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3069–3139 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Waterlogging inhibited photosynthesis and transpiration in Arabidopsis seedlings relative to well-aerated plants.

Taxon
ArabidopsisArabidopsise0
Treatment
waterlogginge0
Outcome
Photosynthesis and transpiratione1
Direction
inhibitede1
Comparator
well-aerated plantse0

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Arabidopsis
Arabidopsis · Taxon · picture of the genus (one of its species)Original uploader was Brona at en.wikipedia . User:Roepers at nl.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Arabidopsis seedlings were subjected to waterlogging and compared with well-aerated plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3388–3478 · show in text ↑
e1

“Photosynthesis and transpiration were inhibited by waterlogging”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3480–3543 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Waterlogging increased relative transcript abundance of ADH, PDC-1 and NIP2;1 in Arabidopsis plants relative to well-aerated plants.

Taxon
ArabidopsisArabidopsise0
Treatment
Waterlogginge1
Gene
ADH, PDC-1, and NIP2;1e1
Outcome
relative transcript abundancee1
Direction
increasede1
Comparator
well-aerated plantse0

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Arabidopsis
Arabidopsis · Taxon · picture of the genus (one of its species)Original uploader was Brona at en.wikipedia . User:Roepers at nl.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Arabidopsis seedlings were subjected to waterlogging and compared with well-aerated plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3388–3478 · show in text ↑
e1

“Waterlogging increased the relative transcript abundance of ADH, PDC-1, and NIP2;1 in plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3545–3637 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

After 24 and 48 hours of waterlogging, relative transcript abundance of most PIPs in Arabidopsis decreased.

Taxon
ArabidopsisArabidopsise0
Treatment
24 and 48 hours of waterlogginge1
Gene
PIPse1
Outcome
relative transcript abundancee1
Direction
decreasede1

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Arabidopsis
Arabidopsis · Taxon · picture of the genus (one of its species)Original uploader was Brona at en.wikipedia . User:Roepers at nl.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Arabidopsis seedlings were subjected to waterlogging and compared with well-aerated plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3388–3478 · show in text ↑
e1

“After 24 and 48 hours of waterlogging, relative transcript abundance of most of the PIPs decreased”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3639–3737 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivesignificant (as stated)measured

Claim · model-written summary

In waterlogged Arabidopsis roots, PIP1;1 and PIP1;4 transcript abundance was significantly higher than in aerated roots, which may indicate a role in resistance under hypoxia.

Taxon
ArabidopsisArabidopsise0
Organ / stage
waterlogged rootse1
Treatment
waterloggede1
Gene
PIP1;1 and PIP1;4e1
Outcome
relative transcript abundancee1
Direction
highere1
Qualifier
may play a role in plant resistance mechanisms under hypoxic conditionse2
Comparator
aerated rootse1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Arabidopsis
Arabidopsis · Taxon · picture of the genus (one of its species)Original uploader was Brona at en.wikipedia . User:Roepers at nl.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Arabidopsis seedlings were subjected to waterlogging and compared with well-aerated plants”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3388–3478 · show in text ↑
e1

“while PIP1;1 and PIP1;4 in waterlogged roots exhibited significantly higher relative transcript abundance compared with aerated roots”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3739–3872 · show in text ↑
e2

“may play a role in plant resistance mechanisms under hypoxic conditions”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 3894–3965 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultsignificant (as stated)measured

Claim · model-written summary

Over-expression of NtPIP1;3 in yeast significantly increased O2 uptake rates in suspension culture.

Taxon
N. tabacumNicotiana tabacume0
Treatment
over-expression of NtPIP1;3 in yeastse1
Gene
NtPIP1;3e1
Outcome
O2 uptake ratese1
Direction
increasede1

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“N. tabacum PIP1;3”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 4172–4189 · show in text ↑
e1

“The over-expression of NtPIP1;3 in yeasts significantly increased their O2 uptake rates in suspension culture”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 4294–4403 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Seven-day root hypoxia sharply increased relative transcript abundance of NtPIP1;3 in tobacco roots in hydroponic culture.

Taxon
N. tabacumNicotiana tabacume0
Organ / stage
rootse0
Treatment
seven-day hypoxia treatmente0
Gene
NtPIP1;3e0
Outcome
relative transcript abundancee0
Direction
increasee0
Setting
hydroponic culturee0

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In N. tabacum roots subjected to hypoxic conditions in hydroponic culture, it demonstrated a sharp increase in the relative transcript abundance of the O2-transporting aquaporin NtPIP1;3 after seven-day hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 4405–4625 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Seven-day root hypoxia increased root ATP levels in tobacco, particularly in apical root segments.

Taxon
N. tabacumNicotiana tabacume0
Organ / stage
apical root segmentse1
Treatment
seven-day hypoxia treatmente0
Outcome
root ATP levelse1
Direction
increasee1

Not reportedComparator

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Nicotiana tabacum
Nicotiana tabacum · TaxonJom / Joachim Müllerchen · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“In N. tabacum roots subjected to hypoxic conditions in hydroponic culture, it demonstrated a sharp increase in the relative transcript abundance of the O2-transporting aquaporin NtPIP1;3 after seven-day hypoxia treatment”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 4405–4625 · show in text ↑
e1

“accompanied by the increase in root ATP levels, particularly in the apical root segments”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 4627–4715 · show in text ↑

flooding · molecular: expression · Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco)Positive and negative results

2 papers: 1 positive, 1 negative or no effect

1 in the opposite direction

  1. positive
See all 2 papers →

flooding · molecular: metabolites · Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco)Positive and negative results

8 papers: 2 positive, 6 negative or no effect

5 papers in the same direction as this paper · 2 in the opposite direction

  1. positive
  2. positive
  3. negative

4 papers more in this group

See all 8 papers →

flooding · molecular: expression · ArabidopsisPositive and negative results

11 papers: 6 positive, 5 negative or no effect

5 papers in the same direction as this paper · 5 in the opposite direction

  1. negative
  2. negative
  3. negative

7 papers more in this group

See all 11 papers →

flooding · physiology: photosynthesis · ArabidopsisResults agree

2 papers: 0 positive, 2 negative or no effect

1 paper in the same direction as this paper

  1. negative
See all 2 papers →

flooding · physiology: photosynthesis · Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco)Results agree

6 papers: 0 positive, 6 negative or no effect

5 papers in the same direction as this paper

  1. negative
  2. negative
  3. negative

2 papers more in this group

See all 6 papers →

Claims are grouped by organism, treatment and what was measured or targeted. A paper counts as positive when any of its claims in the group is positive.