manganese atom · Growth · Glycine max (soybean)
43 claims from these papers; 6 citations between them.
Papers whose results differ, checked claim by claim 19
19 pairs of papers on this question report results that differ: an effect in one paper, the opposite effect or no effect in the other. Two model reviewers reading both claims accepted each pair.
- Evaluation of catalase and peroxidase activity as indicators of Fe and Mn nutrition for soybean (1986)
decreaseExcess Mn depressed soybean growth.
Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
What separates themSituation: toxic level · not statedCompare the two papers → - Effect of the Various Concentration of Manganese and Boron in Culture Solutino on the Growth of Soybean (1952)
decreaseExcess manganese reduced vegetative growth and reproductive activity.
Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
What separates themTest system: controlled environment · laboratorySituation: toxic level · not statedCompare the two papers → - Growth and manganese uptake by soybean in highly calcareous soils as affected by native and applied manganese and predicted by nine different extractants (1995)
increaseMn application increased soybean dry matter in most soils.
Effect of manganese excess on the soybean plant cultivated under various growth conditions (1994)decreaseHigh manganese supply significantly decreased the dry weight of soybean pods.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - COPPER, MANGANESE, AND ZINC FERTILIZATION EFFECTS ON GROWTH OF SOYBEAN ON A CALCAREOUS SOIL (2002)
increaseManganese showed only a trend toward increased soybean biomass.
Effect of chromium and manganese metal on biomass and growth rate of some pulses (2015)decreasemanganese reduced biomass and growth rate of Glycine max.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)
no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
Characterization of Metal Tolerance Proteins and Functional Analysis of GmMTP8.1 Involved in Manganese Tolerance in Soybean (2021)decreaseExcess manganese inhibited soybean plant growth.
What separates themSituation: not stated · toxic levelCompare the two papers → - Effect of manganese excess on the soybean plant cultivated under various growth conditions (1994)
decreaseHigh manganese supply significantly decreased the dry weight of soybean pods.
Evaluation of manganese inorganic fertilizer sources and Mehlich‐3 extractant for prediction of manganese deficiency in soybeans on a Sharkey silty clay (1992)increaseApplied manganese increased soybean dry weight only on Sharkey-A soil, especially when limed.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers →
Show 13 more pairs
- Effect of manganese excess on the soybean plant cultivated under various growth conditions (1994)
decreaseHigh manganese supply significantly decreased the dry weight of soybean pods.
INTERACTION BETWEEN RESISTANCE INDUCER AND MICRONUTRIENTS ON THE CONTROL OF ROOT-LESION NEMATODE AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF SOYBEAN PLANTS (2020)increaseSpraying plants with Mn increased shoot dry weight of soybean.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)
no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
Transcriptome Sequencing Analysis of Root in Soybean Responding to Mn Poisoning (2023)decreaseManganese poisoning inhibited root growth.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)
no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
Metabolic Responses to Manganese Toxicity in Soybean Roots and Leaves (2023)decreaseMn stress inhibited growth and development of soybeans compared with the control
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)
no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
Glycogen Synthase Kinase 3 (GSK3) Gene Family in Glycine max Under the Effect of Manganese Stress (2026)decreaseManganese stress pronouncedly inhibited root elongation and leaf growth in soybean.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Evaluation of catalase and peroxidase activity as indicators of Fe and Mn nutrition for soybean (1986)
decreaseExcess Mn depressed soybean growth.
Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
What separates themDose: 5 mg/L · 0.1 mg/LTest system: controlled environment · laboratorySituation: toxic level · not statedCompare the two papers → - Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)
no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
Effect of the Various Concentration of Manganese and Boron in Culture Solutino on the Growth of Soybean (1952)decreaseExcess manganese reduced vegetative growth and reproductive activity.
What separates themSituation: not stated · toxic levelCompare the two papers → - Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)
no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
What separates themTest system: controlled environment · laboratoryCompare the two papers → - Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)
increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
Characterization of Metal Tolerance Proteins and Functional Analysis of GmMTP8.1 Involved in Manganese Tolerance in Soybean (2021)decreaseExcess manganese inhibited soybean plant growth.
What separates themTest system: laboratory · controlled environmentSituation: not stated · toxic levelCompare the two papers → - Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse (1978)
no changeLow manganese additions produced no significant top growth response.
Effect of chromium and manganese metal on biomass and growth rate of some pulses (2015)decreasemanganese reduced biomass and growth rate of Glycine max.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of chromium and manganese metal on biomass and growth rate of some pulses (2015)
decreasemanganese reduced biomass and growth rate of Glycine max.
Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)
increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
Transcriptome Sequencing Analysis of Root in Soybean Responding to Mn Poisoning (2023)decreaseManganese poisoning inhibited root growth.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)
increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
Metabolic Responses to Manganese Toxicity in Soybean Roots and Leaves (2023)decreaseMn stress inhibited growth and development of soybeans compared with the control
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers → - Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean (2007)
increaseSuitable manganese concentrations improved root development and aboveground growth.
Glycogen Synthase Kinase 3 (GSK3) Gene Family in Glycine max Under the Effect of Manganese Stress (2026)decreaseManganese stress pronouncedly inhibited root elongation and leaf growth in soybean.
The records name no dose, test system or situation that separates the two claims.Compare the two papers →
How these papers cite each other
6 citations between these papers: 6 on the same side, 0 across the two sides.
- Positive result
- Negative result or no effect
- Citation, pointing to the cited paper
- Citation across the two sides
- Larger circle: more citations overall
Years run left to right. Citations come from the papers’ OpenAlex reference lists. Hover a paper to bring forward its citations; click it to open the paper.
Papers reporting a positive result 13
- positive
Effect of Temperature on Soybean Growth and Manganese Accumulation1 · 1981
- positive
- positive
- positive
- positive
- positive
COPPER, MANGANESE, AND ZINC FERTILIZATION EFFECTS ON GROWTH OF SOYBEAN ON A CALCAREOUS SOIL · 2002
- positive
Effect of boron and manganese application on the agronomic characters of soybean · 2005
- positive
Effect of Manganese on Seedling-building of Soybean · 2007
- positive
- positive
- positive
Differential response of roots growth of soybean germplasm under low pH and manganese toxicity · 2017
- positive
- no effect
- negative
- positive
- positive
Foliar application of manganese sources on glyphosate-resistant soybean in no-tillage · 2023
- positive
Critical Limit of Manganese for Soybean in Soils of Three Agro-Ecological Zones of Bangladesh · 2023
- positive
Papers reporting a negative result or no effect 18
- negative
Effect of Mn on growth, modulation, and nitrogen fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse · 1978
- no effect
- negative
Transport and distribution of manganese in two cultivars of soybean ( Glycine max (L.) Merr.) · 1980
- negative
- negative
Evaluation of catalase and peroxidase activity as indicators of Fe and Mn nutrition for soybean · 1986
- negative
- negative
Effect of manganese excess on the soybean plant cultivated under various growth conditions · 1994
- negative
- no effect
Changes in anatomy and root cell ultrastructure of soybean genotypes under manganese stress · 2009
- negative
RESIDUAL EFFECTS OF MANGANESE SULFATE ON GROWTH AND ON MANGANESE UPTAKE IN SOYBEAN · 2011
- no effect
- negative
Effect of chromium and manganese metal on biomass and growth rate of some pulses · 2015
- negative
- negative
Effects of manganese toxicity on the growth of soybean (Glycine max L.) at the seedling stage · 2021
- negative
Effects of Manganese Toxicity on the Growth and Gene Expression at the Seedling Stage of Soybean · 2022
- no effect
- no effect
- negative
- negative
- negative
- negative
Transcriptome Sequencing Analysis of Root in Soybean Responding to Mn Poisoning · 2023
- negative
Metabolic Responses to Manganese Toxicity in Soybean Roots and Leaves · 2023
- negative
EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT CONCENTRATIONS OF Cu+, Mn+, AND Ni+ IONS ON GLYCINE MAX GERMINATION · 2024
- negative
Glycogen Synthase Kinase 3 (GSK3) Gene Family in Glycine max Under the Effect of Manganese Stress · 2026
- negative
A paper is on the positive side when any of its claims here is positive. Claims are grouped by organism, treatment and what was measured or targeted. Claims that compare genotypes are left out; a claim about lacking a nutrient counts the other way round in that nutrient’s question. “Results differ” marks a question where two model reviewers, reading both claims, accepted at least one pair of papers whose results differ.